-
Olivia James commented on the post, "Train I Ride:" The Downfall of the Train in Twentieth Century African American Religious Perspectives of the Mississippi Delta, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
First, I really enjoyed your analysis. You took your research a step further contrasting the symbolism of the train during the time of the film until today. It is interesting how the theme of religion drifted away […]
-
Carly McWilliams commented on the post, Performance Aspects of Chanted Railroad Sermons, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Thanks for trying out my questions, Hannah! I really like your last point about Zeke’s ending compared to other characters like Chick and Hotshot. While they both made individual decisions that led to their fate, […]
-
Carly McWilliams commented on the post, A Capella and Speech to Song, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Hi Hannah! I read up a little bit about the musical In Transit that you linked on your post, and it sounds really interesting!! According to its website, the story is supposed to follow “the intertwined lives of […]
-
Carly McWilliams commented on the post, King Vidor’s Hallelujah! Another Black Experience Told From a White Perspective: Pardon My Biased Breakdown Below , on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Olivia, I really enjoyed reading your post and the questions that followed. I was interested in seeing how the general public reacted to Hallelujah when it came out in 1929, and if they shared the same thoughts as […]
-
Leslie Wingard wrote a new post on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
“Death’s Black Train” captures the temptation and redemption of religion, Christianity to be specific. It is the idea that the inevitable is coming, death, and one should be “saved” before then. The author say […]
-
Rekik Ziku commented on the post, Celebrity Preachers, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Thank you Ty!!!
-
Rekik Ziku commented on the post, Celebrity Preachers, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Thank you, and it was interesting to see him grow from “just a cotton picker” to a preacher.
-
Rekik Ziku commented on the post, Celebrity Preachers, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Hey Sam, That’s a good question. I noticed that they too were getting more respect after Zeke became a preacher, and a specific scene that stood out to me was when they were passing by the community on a carriage […]
-
Rekik Ziku commented on the post, Music Brings People Together Regardless of Social Injustice, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Hi Mason, I liked that you wrote about how different types of music are used to bring people together and show emotions. When I was preparing for my blog post, I read that music is relevant in black culture […]
-
Jackeb-Eligah Milan wrote a new post on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
The chapter, “Train Travel and the Black Religious Imagination” in the book After Redemption: Jim Crow and the Transformation of African American Religion in the Delta by John M. Giggie deals with Delta blacks and […]
-
Hannah Groetsch commented on the post, Celebrity Preachers, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Hi Rekik, I think you make a great point about the whole parade and cheering crowds being similar to the attention and authority granted to celebrity preachers in modern day. I think the idea of being well known […]
-
Hannah Groetsch commented on the post, Performance Aspects of Chanted Railroad Sermons, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Hi Carly! I also liked getting to see Zeke dress up and act out the train analogy. The question you pose is interesting because even while acting as the “conductor” Zeke himself is led astray multiple times, and I […]
-
Eliza Cullen commented on the post, The Theme of Two Trains Passed Through Art Forms, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
That is a really interesting about Chick being the last to leave on the train. It did seem like she was hesitant to get on, so maybe it was her choosing between heaven and hell. It reminded me of the line in […]
-
Eliza Cullen commented on the post, Performance Aspects of Chanted Railroad Sermons, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
That is very interesting that Giggie wrote about how the song itself sounded like a train. I would not have picked that up but going back and listening again, I can see that it does have some similarities.
-
Samuel Boudreau commented on the post, Celebrity Preachers, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Hi Rekik, this is an interesting post on how the success of a preacher can impact how they view themselves. My question to you is how do you think the popularity of Zeke and his family changed how they viewed […]
-
Ty commented on the post, Celebrity Preachers, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Hi Rekik, I agree that the fame that preachers get from technology can go to their heads and distract from the initial message. I too find it interesting how that concept was conveyed in the film even without the […]
-
Cole Ward commented on the post, Music, Death and Sorrow, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
I appreciate how you extrapolated and connected the themes from the movie and gods trombone. Music is a way to express a lot of difficult emotions and you captured how the movie worked that in well.
-
Ty commented on the post, Hallelujah for Dr. Lerone Martin, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Hi Abby, I did not know about the West African tradition you referenced in your post and find it very intriguing and cool that it was incorporated in the movie. I also think about the profit that comes with […]
-
Olivia James wrote a new post on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
As I was watching King Vidor’s Hallelujah (1929), my initial reaction of intrigue quickly disintegrated into annoyance and finally confusion. In this short reaction, I will point out what I questioned about t […]

-
Samuel Boudreau commented on the post, Representation for Whom?, on the site Religion in Black Film and Literature (Fall 2020) 5 years, 4 months ago
Hi Ty,
You bring up a lot of great points, and I think, to answer your question, the film further damaged the black subconscious self image by attempting to show that the social movements of the 1920s would be […] - Load More